Published on November 19th, 2019 | by John OMeara



On a night when weather and a major incident reduced attendance, last Thursday’s Handsworth Wood Ward Forum provided constructive discussion with the police, but also further evidence of a democratic deficit in areas of Handsworth, which leaves it at a serious disadvantage as the Council continues to devolve responsibility to local areas.

There had been no Forum meeting in Handsworth Wood for 6 months, but Chair Councillor Gurdial Singh Atwal offered no explanation of this. He couldn’t remember when he had last spoken to his co-councillor Narinder Kaur Kooner, and showed no sign of having made any preparation for the meeting.

Residents said that there didn’t appear to be any carry-over from one meeting to another, for example on gaining representation on a city-wide forum on HMO/hostel issues, so the same discussion happened again and again. Councillor Atwal was asked what the Council was doing on these issues, the major ones for residents over the last 2 years, and he said ‘I don’t have a clue’.

It must surely be a minimum requirement for the roll-out of the Council’s devolution policy that the councillor network is capable of supporting and promoting it.`One resident had made special efforts to attend a Forum for the first time, but sent us a message afterwards saying:

“I felt the meeting was a waste of my time…Councillor Atwal was completely inefficient, not really interested in residents’ issues leaving all present frustrated…I was very disappointed and won’t be attending any further meetings.”

Our view is that in as far as we have a ‘democratic deficit’ it is all the more important that as many residents as possible attend the ward forum meetings – still the best means of access to those who can influence and change our local services.

Issues discussed:

Police Issues:

1. Dangerous driving and parking: a resident described a recent high speed collision with the wall outside her house on Church Lane (picture left is of another wall nearby which suffered the same fate). She also described an earlier ‘write-off’ of the family’s car, and said both incidents were examples of the unnaceptable driving speeds on that road and many others in the area.

Several people raised concerns about the parking outside Handsworth Wood Girls Academy at the start and end of the school day. When the picture below was taken half the cars also had their engines running for up to 20 minutes.

Sgt. Dom McGrath said he would take action on three fronts: he would have a discussion with the Head of the Girls’ School about writing a letter to all parents about the issue, he would talk to the Streetwatch Team about doing a ‘speedwatch’ exercise on Church Lane, and he would talk to the Sgt. of the Perry Barr Road Harm Reduction Team about use of their educational and enforcement capability.

Sgt. McGrath was initially doubtful about his team’s ability to address parking outside other schools which posed a threat to both safety and health, but then seemed to come round to the view that they could do more on this, and that he would be looking at repeating his discussion with the Girls’ Academy Head at other schools.

Councillor Atwal asked if the police could produce a short film on parking for the public which could be used at parents’ evenings etc, and Sgt. McGrath seemed to be considering this.

2. HMO’s/Supported Housing: the police have been working closely with Handsworth Wood Residents’ Association on properties in Cornwall Road and Wheaton Vale where there has been anti-social behaviour allied to alcohol and other drug use. Sgt. McGrath suggested there were two options from here:

a. collate all the complaints then call the owners in, set out what is required of them, and issue a first warning letter. If there is no improvement, a second letter will be issued. The third stage involves a closure order, but is hard to achieve due to the consistency of information required over an extended period.

b. the residents association provide a letter summarising the complaints, and the police invite the owners to meet with the residents to discuss these and what can done about them. This has been found to be quite a ‘powerful’ tool in the past, even though the owners’ involvement is voluntary. If it gets nowhere it provides further evidence in a legal approach.

Although next steps weren’t pinned down at the meeting, it seems the Residents’ Association need to let Sgt. McGrath know which route they prefer.

3. 20 mph speed limit: not strictly a police issue at this stage, but linked to the road safety discussion. Residents wanted to know what progress there was on extending 20mph limits to this area. Lesley Bannister said she would enquire about inviting the Senior Highways Engineer to the March meeting, and also ask him to provide feedback on the evaluation of the impacts of the reduced speed limit in the South and East of the city. A petition may be considered in the future.

4. Crime stats: there has been a dramatic reduction in the number of burglaries. In the last 6 weeks there have been 4 burglaries, compared to the same period last year when there were between 30 and 40. In the last year 12 prolific burglars have been arrested, and most of these have been sentenced to 3 years or more in prison.

5. Police sugeries: the next police surgery, where anyone can come and discuss a concern, is at Uplands Allotments on 30th November between 10am and 2pm.

6. Neighbourhood Tasking Group meetings: designed as an opportunity for local agencies, including the police, to come together with councillors and resident representatives, summarise current issues for the local area, and decide who is best placed to take action on each issue. Sgt. McGrath said that no Handsworth Wood councillors had attended the last 2 meetings. There is some difficulty with the Handsworth Wood police area also including some of Handsworth ward, but there is less of an issue for Handsworth Wood than other wards.

6. All Out Day 22nd November: we are awaiting further information from the police.

Residents’ Issues:

1. HMO’s/Supported Housing/Planning: as well as the aspiration to have meaningful involvement in planning and other issues re. HMO’s (one element of the Ward Plan is ‘Debate – being involved in policy making’), residents said they wanted to see increased clarity and control in supported housing. They are aware of the exploitation of Housing Benefit and support funding by unscrupulous ‘providers’ who fail to provide support, and see the results every day on the street.

Councillor Atwal seemed unaware of these issues, and the levels of payment which have several times been confirmed by the Council’s officers (Matt Smith at the 20.9.18. Ward Forum described the situation as ‘a runaway train’). He asked for someone to provide him with one example in the ward so he could deal with it. It was suggested he speak to PCSO Sam Shaw who has been wrestling with the issues for months, for example in Endwood Court Road.

Councillor Kooner has asked for the Private Rented Team to present their ‘roadshow’ at the January meeting. This was welcomed, but the request made that as well as presenting information there be the time and capacity to discuss how residents are going to be more involved in planning decisions and policy making, and real insight provided into what the Council is doing to produce change at a national level in the way supported housing is regulated.

2. Leaves: the combination of wetness and fallen leaves has made pavements dangerous. Residents sought clarification of the Council policy on clearing leaves – some had been told that they would only be cleared once, and that any additional clearances would have to be done by residents. There is concern about safety, and liability if for example an older person is injured. Councillor Atwal said he would check on the policy and talk to the Cabinet member about it.

3. Clinical Commissioning Group: at present we are part of the Sandwell and West Birmingham CCG (the group which purchases the majority our community and hospital health care), but there is now discussion about amalgamating with Birmingham and Solihull CCG to produce a single organisation. The CCG is looking for opportunities to discuss the effects of this change with as many ‘stakeholders’ as possible. It was suggested that they be invited to a Ward Forum as early as possible in 2019.

Date of next meeting: to be confirmed (priority items will be the Ward Plan and HMO’s/Supported Housing).

About the Author


  1. DAVID says:

    Well done John for your efforts. Good and positive work for the community.

  2. Anita says:

    Just come across this article, reading the above comments about the 2 councillors namely Mr Gurdial Singh Atwal and Narinder Kaur Kooner. I totally agree it would be nice if we had a decent, reliable professional Councillor that actually had an interest in the residents of HW and all cared about all communities and not just pick and choose who they want to help and support (those they are related to and befriend for votes for bribery), this is what I see happening in Handsworth Wood by these to Councillors for years. Narinder Kooner doesn’t respond or action tasks when asked so unprofessional, yet loves to take the credit when residents take initiative upon themsekves and go to other MPs/Councillors outside of Handsworthwood Ward Constiguency . Narinder Kaur Kooner is a very close relative of Gurdial Singh Atwal he knew alot of people within the Sikh community and on that basis she was handed the role in a olate? ( It’s all about numbers in their eyes thats how she got OBE just had a clicky associates who nominated her? Once again clicky’ numbers game? Appalling about the £320,000 taxpayers & HandsworthWood’ residents money exactly where has it been spent? where’s the accountability of the trust directors transparency of funds? And why are these both disgust me for their dishonesty uncle & niece (Councillors Gurdial Atwal and Narinder Kaur Kooner) why are they both not declaring their expenses in public? What are they hiding? Your right personal gain maybe and yes a full investigation need to be carried out!!!

  3. ALISON says:

    Re: The comment quoted above – Here is a prime example of someone who was elected to public office completely ignoring their civic and moral responsibilities – have you no shame, Councillor Atwal?, You demonstrate via this comment, a complete lack of respect for both fellow councillors &BCC Officers and for those residents you are PAID to represent. You have a moral obligation to make sure you DO have a clue! What city do you live in?

  4. Councillor Atwal is also one of the four directors of the Handsworth Wood Community Development Trust, which runs the Pavilion. The Trust describes itself on its website as ‘a community-led organisation’. But it is curiously secretive.

    The Trust has a website with a Blog and Latest posts, but the most recent is January 2017, and the latest Facebook post is December 2018.

    The website claims that ‘The Handsworth Wood Community Development Trust is a community-led organisation.’ Who runs it? The website says ‘The Directors have a passion, commitment, dedication, energy and desire to see new solutions to presenting problems and emerging challenges.’ But it doesn’t say who the directors are. For that you will have to go to the Companies House website, which states that there are 4 directors: Cllr Atwal, Dr Pyara Bhogal who is the chair, Ms Usha Khera and Matthew Lloyd. Who are these three people? What do they do? Do they ever come to HW Forum meetings? When were they elected and for how long?

    The website says ‘The Board meets quarterly’. But these meetings are in secret. There is no agenda published, no reports are published, and no HW citizens are able to observe let alone contribute.

    The website claims that ‘The Trust is working with a range of partners to deliver Jobs and business opportunities; Health & wellbeing activities; Education, learning and skills development; Safer, stronger and cohesive neighbourhoods; Community planning, engagement & local action.’ Now we all know that the Pavilion does some good things. But these are big claims: where are the regular reports of actions, outcomes and costs? Who are these partners and how were they chosen?

    In short, the Trust is NOT ‘community-led’. It is time that there was a wholesale re-launch of the Trust – this time on a proper basis, democratically run and publicly accountable to the people of Handsworth Wood.

    • Archie says:

      Atwal has claimed approx £320,000 in expenses from brummie council tax payers. All honest cllrs list thier expenses on line, Our MP Khalid lists all his expenses on line but Atwal & Kooner have refused point blank to show how much money they have claimed for providing a very poor service to HW citizens.

      Residents should write to Bham
      council monitoring & legal officer complaining about this appalling democratic deficit.

      Why have the two cllrs hidden their close family relationship. Why do atwal pretend to not have spoken to each other form months when they are part of the same extended family. What are they trying to hide?

      Is the Community Development Trust being used by Atwal for personal gain?

      Google bham Mail for more facts as they reported that Atwal was taking payment from a bham businessman to get planning permission for his shop but Atwal failed to get planning approval and the businessman complained to the Mail about Atwals behaviour.

      Surely this should have disqualified Atwal from political office. Contact the Mail or Labours Regional Office for more info about their internal investigations into Atwal.

      It’s a shame cllr Hamilton was driven out of HW, she always responded quickly to citizens enquiries.

  5. Tony walker says:

    It would be nice to have a councillor who had an interest in his community. It made me laugh that he suggested making a film about parking! Just give them all a ticket and a copy of the Highway Code, job done. Do you really think there selfish people are going to take notice of a film!

  6. Paulette Hamilton says:

    Interesting article

  7. Lorna Phillip says:

    Thank you for the update!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Top ↑